| 20262025/26 | | Connor McDavid, Nathan MacKinnon |
| 20252024/25 | | Leon Draisaitl, Nikita Kucherov |
| 20242023/24 | | Nikita Kucherov, Connor McDavid |
| 20232022/23 | | David Pastrňák🇨🇿, Matthew Tkachuk |
| 20222021/22 | | Connor McDavid, Igor Shesterkin |
| 20212020/21 | | Auston Matthews, Nathan MacKinnon |
| 20202019/20 | | Nathan MacKinnon, Artemi Panarin |
| 20192018/19 | | Sidney Crosby, Connor McDavid |
| 20182017/18 | | Nathan MacKinnon, Anze Kopitar |
| 20172016/17 | | Sidney Crosby, Sergei Bobrovsky |
| 20162015/16 | | Sidney Crosby, Jamie Benn |
| 20152014/15 |   Carey PriceMontréal Canadiens | Alex Ovechkin, John Tavares |
| 20142013/14 | | Ryan Getzlaf, Claude Giroux |
| 20132012/13 | | Sidney Crosby, John Tavares |
| 20122011/12 | | Steven Stamkos, Henrik Lundqvist |
| 20112010/11 | | Daniel Sedin, Martin St. Louis |
| 20102009/10 |   Henrik SedinVancouver Canucks | Alex Ovechkin, Sidney Crosby |
| 20092008/09 | | Evgeni Malkin, Pavel Datsyuk |
| 20082007/08 | | Evgeni Malkin, Jarome Iginla |
| 20072006/07 | | Roberto Luongo, Martin Brodeur |
| 20062005/06 |   Joe ThorntonSan Jose Sharks | Jaromír Jágr🇨🇿, Miikka Kiprusoff |
| 20042003/04 |   Martin St. LouisTampa Bay Lightning | Jarome Iginla, Martin Brodeur |
| 20032002/03 |   Peter ForsbergColorado Avalanche | Markus Naslund, Martin Brodeur |
| 20022001/02 | Jose TheodoreMontréal Canadiens | Jarome Iginla, Patrick Roy |
| 20012000/01 | Joe SakicColorado Avalanche | Mario Lemieux, Jaromír Jágr🇨🇿 |
| 20001999/00 |   Chris ProngerSt. Louis Blues | Jaromír Jágr🇨🇿, Pavel Bure |
| 19991998/99 |   Jaromír Jágr🇨🇿Pittsburgh Penguins | Alexei Yashin, Dominik Hašek🇨🇿 |
| 19981997/98 |   Dominik Hašek🇨🇿Buffalo Sabres | Jaromír Jágr🇨🇿, Teemu Selanne |
| 19971996/97 | Dominik Hašek🇨🇿Buffalo Sabres | Paul Kariya, Mario Lemieux |
| 19961995/96 | Mario LemieuxPittsburgh Penguins | Mark Messier, Eric Lindros |
| 19951994/95 |   Eric LindrosPhiladelphia Flyers | Jaromír Jágr🇨🇿, Dominik Hašek🇨🇿 |
| 19941993/94 |   Sergei FedorovDetroit Red Wings | Dominik Hašek🇨🇿, John Vanbiesbrouck |
| 19931992/93 | Mario LemieuxPittsburgh Penguins | Doug Gilmour, Pat LaFontaine |
| 19921991/92 |   Mark MessierNew York Rangers | Patrick Roy, Brett Hull |
| 19911990/91 | Brett HullSt. Louis Blues | Wayne Gretzky, Ed Belfour |
| 19901989/90 |   Mark MessierEdmonton Oilers | Ray Bourque, Brett Hull |
| 19891988/89 |   Wayne GretzkyLos Angeles Kings | Mario Lemieux, Steve Yzerman |
| 19881987/88 | Mario LemieuxPittsburgh Penguins | Grant Fuhr, Wayne Gretzky |
| 19871986/87 | Wayne GretzkyEdmonton Oilers | Ray Bourque, Mike Liut |
| 19861985/86 | Wayne GretzkyEdmonton Oilers | Mario Lemieux, Mark Howe |
| 19851984/85 | Wayne GretzkyEdmonton Oilers | Dale Hawerchuk, Pelle Lindbergh |
| 19841983/84 | Wayne GretzkyEdmonton Oilers | Rod Langway, Bryan Trottier |
| 19831982/83 | Wayne GretzkyEdmonton Oilers | Pete Peeters, Denis Savard |
| 19821981/82 | Wayne GretzkyEdmonton Oilers | Bryan Trottier, Mike Bossy |
| 19811980/81 | Wayne GretzkyEdmonton Oilers | Mike Liut, Marcel Dionne |
| 19801979/80 | Wayne GretzkyEdmonton Oilers | Marcel Dionne, Tony Esposito |
| 19791978/79 |   Bryan TrottierNew York Islanders | Guy Lafleur, Marcel Dionne |
| 19781977/78 | Guy LafleurMontréal Canadiens | Bryan Trottier, Darryl Sittler |
| 19771976/77 | Guy LafleurMontréal Canadiens | Bobby Clarke, Rogie Vachon |
| 19761975/76 | Bobby ClarkePhiladelphia Flyers | Denis Potvin, Guy Lafleur |
| 19751974/75 | Bobby ClarkePhiladelphia Flyers | Rogie Vachon, Bobby Orr |
| 19741973/74 |   Phil EspositoBoston Bruins | Bernie Parent, Bobby Orr |
| 19731972/73 | Bobby ClarkePhiladelphia Flyers | Phil Esposito, Bobby Orr |
| 19721971/72 | Bobby OrrBoston Bruins | Ken Dryden, Phil Esposito |
| 19711970/71 | Bobby OrrBoston Bruins | Phil Esposito, Bobby Hull |
| 19701969/70 | Bobby OrrBoston Bruins | Tony Esposito, Red Berenson |
| 19691968/69 | Phil EspositoBoston Bruins | Jean Beliveau, Bobby Orr |
| 19681967/68 |   Stan Mikita🇸🇰Chicago Blackhawks | Jean Beliveau, Bobby Hull |
| 19671966/67 | Stan Mikita🇸🇰Chicago Blackhawks | Ed Giacomin, Bobby Hull |
| 19661965/66 | Bobby HullChicago Blackhawks | Jean Beliveau, Gordie Howe |
| 19651964/65 | Bobby HullChicago Blackhawks | Norm Ullman, Gordie Howe |
| 19641963/64 | Jean BeliveauMontréal Canadiens | Bobby Hull, Gordie Howe |
| 19631962/63 | Gordie HoweDetroit Red Wings | Stan Mikita🇸🇰, Terry Sawchuk |
| 19621961/62 | Jacques PlanteMontréal Canadiens | Doug Harvey, Bobby Hull |
| 19611960/61 | Bernie GeoffrionMontréal Canadiens | Johnny Bower, Gordie Howe |
| 19601959/60 | Gordie HoweDetroit Red Wings | Bobby Hull, Glenn Hall |
| 19591958/59 | Andy BathgateNew York Rangers | Gordie Howe, Jean Beliveau |
| 19581957/58 | Gordie HoweDetroit Red Wings | Andy Bathgate, Doug Harvey |
| 19571956/57 | Gordie HoweDetroit Red Wings | Jean Beliveau, Andy Bathgate |
| 19561955/56 | Jean BeliveauMontréal Canadiens | Tod Sloan, Gump Worsley |
| 19551954/55 |   Ted KennedyToronto Maple Leafs | Harry Lumley, Maurice Richard |
| 19541953/54 | Al RollinsChicago Blackhawks | Red Kelly, Maurice Richard |
| 19531952/53 | Gordie HoweDetroit Red Wings | Al Rollins, Red Kelly |
| 19521951/52 | Gordie HoweDetroit Red Wings | Elmer Lach, Jim Henry |
| 19511950/51 | Milt SchmidtBoston Bruins | Maurice Richard, Red Kelly |
| 19501949/50 | Chuck RaynerNew York Rangers | Ted Kennedy, Maurice Richard |
| 19491948/49 | Sid AbelDetroit Red Wings | Bill Durnan, Roy Conacher |
| 19481947/48 | Buddy O'ConnorNew York Rangers | Frank Brimsek, Elmer Lach |
| 19471946/47 | Maurice RichardMontréal Canadiens | Milt Schmidt, Max Bentley |
| 19461945/46 | Max BentleyChicago Blackhawks | Gaye Stewart, Bill Durnan |
| 19451944/45 | Elmer LachMontréal Canadiens | Maurice Richard, Bill Cowley |
| 19441943/44 | Babe PrattToronto Maple Leafs | Bill Cowley, Doug Bentley |
| 19431942/43 | Bill CowleyBoston Bruins | Doug Bentley, Syl Apps, Syd Howe |
| 19421941/42 |   Tom AndersonBrooklyn Americans | Syl Apps, Lynn Patrick, Frank Brimsek, Bill Thoms |
| 19411940/41 | Bill CowleyBoston Bruins | Dit Clapper, Syl Apps |
| 19401939/40 | Ebbie GoodfellowDetroit Red Wings | Syl Apps, Dit Clapper |
| 19391938/39 | Toe BlakeMontréal Canadiens | Syl Apps, Johnny Gottselig |
| 19381937/38 | Eddie ShoreBoston Bruins | Paul Thompson, Babe Siebert |
| 19371936/37 | Babe SiebertMontréal Canadiens | Lionel Conacher, Ebbie Goodfellow |
| 19361935/36 | Eddie ShoreBoston Bruins | Hooley Smith, Sweeney Schriner |
| 19351934/35 | Eddie ShoreBoston Bruins | Charlie Conacher, Art Coulter |
| 19341933/34 | Aurel JoliatMontréal Canadiens | Lionel Conacher, King Clancy |
| 19331932/33 | Eddie ShoreBoston Bruins | Bill Cook, John Ross Roach |
| 19321931/32 | Howie MorenzMontréal Canadiens | Ivan Johnson, Hooley Smith |
| 19311930/31 | Howie MorenzMontréal Canadiens | Eddie Shore, King Clancy |
| 19301929/30 |   Nels StewartMontreal Maroons | Lionel Hitchman, Cooney Weiland |
| 19291928/29 |   Roy WortersNew York Americans | Ace Bailey, Eddie Shore |
| 19281927/28 | Howie MorenzMontréal Canadiens | Roy Worters, Eddie Shore |
| 19271926/27 | Herb GardinerMontréal Canadiens | Bill Cook, Frank Fredrickson |
| 19261925/26 | Nels StewartMontreal Maroons | Sprague Cleghorn, Frank Nighbor |
| 19251924/25 |   Billy BurchHamilton Tigers | Howie Morenz, Clint Benedict |
| 19241923/24 |   Frank NighborOttawa Senators (1917) | Sprague Cleghorn, John Ross Roach |
