| 20262025/26 | | – |
| 20252024/25 | | – |
| 20242023/24 | | – |
| 20232022/23 | | – |
| 20222021/22 |   Carey PriceMontréal Canadiens | – |
| 20212020/21 | | – |
| 20202019/20 |   Bobby RyanOttawa Senators | – |
| 20192018/19 |   Robin LehnerNew York Islanders | – |
| 20182017/18 |   Brian BoyleNew Jersey Devils | – |
| 20172016/17 | | – |
| 20162015/16 |   Jaromír Jágr🇨🇿Florida Panthers | – |
| 20152014/15 |   Devan DubnykMinnesota Wild | – |
| 20142013/14 |   Dominic MooreNew York Rangers | – |
| 20132012/13 | Josh HardingMinnesota Wild | – |
| 20122011/12 | | – |
| 20112010/11 |   Ian LaperrierePhiladelphia Flyers | – |
| 20102009/10 |   Jose TheodoreWashington Capitals | – |
| 20092008/09 |   Steve SullivanNashville Predators | – |
| 20082007/08 |   Jason BlakeToronto Maple Leafs | – |
| 20072006/07 | | – |
| 20062005/06 |   Teemu SelanneAnaheim Ducks | – |
| 20042003/04 |   Bryan BerardChicago Blackhawks | – |
| 20032002/03 |   Steve YzermanDetroit Red Wings | – |
| 20022001/02 | Saku KoivuMontréal Canadiens | – |
| 20012000/01 | Adam GravesNew York Rangers | – |
| 20001999/00 | Ken DaneykoNew Jersey Devils | – |
| 19991998/99 |   John CullenTampa Bay Lightning | – |
| 19981997/98 |   Jamie McLennanSt. Louis Blues | – |
| 19971996/97 |   Tony GranatoSan Jose Sharks | – |
| 19961995/96 |   Gary RobertsCalgary Flames | – |
| 19951994/95 |   Pat LaFontaineBuffalo Sabres | – |
| 19941993/94 |   Cam NeelyBoston Bruins | – |
| 19931992/93 |   Mario LemieuxPittsburgh Penguins | – |
| 19921991/92 | Mark FitzpatrickNew York Islanders | – |
| 19911990/91 |   Dave TaylorLos Angeles Kings | – |
| 19901989/90 | Gord KluzakBoston Bruins | – |
| 19891988/89 | Tim KerrPhiladelphia Flyers | – |
| 19881987/88 | Bob BourneLos Angeles Kings | – |
| 19871986/87 |   Doug JarvisHartford Whalers | – |
| 19861985/86 | Charlie SimmerBoston Bruins | – |
| 19851984/85 | Anders HedbergNew York Rangers | – |
| 19841983/84 | Brad ParkDetroit Red Wings | – |
| 19831982/83 | Lanny McDonaldCalgary Flames | – |
| 19821981/82 |   Glenn ReschColorado Rockies | – |
| 19811980/81 | Blake DunlopSt. Louis Blues | – |
| 19801979/80 |   Al MacAdamMinnesota North Stars | – |
| 19791978/79 | Serge SavardMontréal Canadiens | – |
| 19781977/78 | Butch GoringLos Angeles Kings | – |
| 19771976/77 | Ed WestfallNew York Islanders | – |
| 19761975/76 | Rod GilbertNew York Rangers | – |
| 19751974/75 | Don LuceBuffalo Sabres | – |
| 19741973/74 | Henri RichardMontréal Canadiens | – |
| 19731972/73 | Lowell MacDonaldPittsburgh Penguins | – |
| 19721971/72 | Bobby ClarkePhiladelphia Flyers | – |
| 19711970/71 | Jean RatelleNew York Rangers | – |
| 19701969/70 | Pit MartinChicago Blackhawks | – |
| 19691968/69 |   Ted HampsonOakland Seals | – |
| 19681967/68 | Claude ProvostMontréal Canadiens | – |
