| 20262025/26 |   Jon CooperTampa Bay Lightning | Lindy Ruff, Dan Muse |
| 20252024/25 |   Spencer CarberyWashington Capitals | Scott Arniel, Martin St. Louis |
| 20242023/24 |   Rick TocchetVancouver Canucks | Andrew Brunette, Rick Bowness |
| 20232022/23 |   Jim MontgomeryBoston Bruins | Lindy Ruff, Dave Hakstol |
| 20222021/22 |   Darryl SutterCalgary Flames | Andrew Brunette, Gerard Gallant |
| 20212020/21 |   Rod Brind'AmourCarolina Hurricanes | Dean Evason, Joel Quenneville |
| 20202019/20 | Bruce CassidyBoston Bruins | Alain Vigneault, John Tortorella |
| 20192018/19 |   Barry TrotzNew York Islanders | Jon Cooper, Craig Berube |
| 20182017/18 |   Gerard GallantVegas Golden Knights | Bruce Cassidy, Jared Bednar |
| 20172016/17 |   John TortorellaColumbus Blue Jackets | Mike Babcock, Todd McLellan |
| 20162015/16 | Barry TrotzWashington Capitals | Gerard Gallant, Lindy Ruff |
| 20152014/15 | Bob HartleyCalgary Flames | Alain Vigneault, Peter Laviolette |
| 20142013/14 |   Patrick RoyColorado Avalanche | Mike Babcock, Jon Cooper |
| 20132012/13 |   Paul MacLeanOttawa Senators | Joel Quenneville, Bruce Boudreau |
| 20122011/12 |   Ken HitchcockSt. Louis Blues | John Tortorella, Paul MacLean |
| 20112010/11 |   Dan BylsmaPittsburgh Penguins | Alain Vigneault, Barry Trotz |
| 20102009/10 |   Dave TippettPhoenix Coyotes | Barry Trotz, Joe Sacco |
| 20092008/09 | Claude JulienBoston Bruins | Andy Murray, Todd McLellan |
| 20082007/08 | Bruce BoudreauWashington Capitals | Mike Babcock |
| 20072006/07 | Alain VigneaultVancouver Canucks | Michel Therrien |
| 20062005/06 |   Lindy RuffBuffalo Sabres | Tom Renney |
| 20042003/04 | John TortorellaTampa Bay Lightning | Ron Wilson, Darryl Sutter |
| 20032002/03 |   Jacques LemaireMinnesota Wild | John Tortorella, Jacques Martin |
| 20022001/02 | Bob FrancisPhoenix Coyotes | Robbie Ftorek |
| 20012000/01 |   Bill BarberPhiladelphia Flyers | Scotty Bowman, Jacques Martin |
| 20001999/00 | Joel QuennevilleSt. Louis Blues | Ron Wilson |
| 19991998/99 | Jacques MartinOttawa Senators | Ken Hitchcock |
| 19981997/98 | Pat BurnsBoston Bruins | Ken Hitchcock |
| 19971996/97 | Ted NolanBuffalo Sabres | Ken Hitchcock, Jacques Martin |
| 19961995/96 |   Scotty BowmanDetroit Red Wings | Doug MacLean, Terry Crisp |
| 19951994/95 |   Marc CrawfordQuebec Nordiques | Scotty Bowman, Terry Murray |
| 19941993/94 |   Jacques LemaireNew Jersey Devils | John Muckler |
| 19931992/93 |   Pat BurnsToronto Maple Leafs | Pierre Page |
| 19921991/92 | Pat QuinnVancouver Canucks | Roger Neilson, Pat Burns |
| 19911990/91 | Brian SutterSt. Louis Blues | Tom Webster, Mike Keenan |
| 19901989/90 |   Bob MurdochWinnipeg Jets (1979) | Mike Milbury, Roger Neilson |
| 19891988/89 |   Pat BurnsMontréal Canadiens | Bob McCammon, Terry Crisp |
| 19881987/88 | Jacques DemersDetroit Red Wings | Jean Perron |
| 19871986/87 | Jacques DemersDetroit Red Wings | Dan Maloney |
| 19861985/86 |   Glen SatherEdmonton Oilers | Jacques Demers, Lorne Henning |
| 19851984/85 | Mike KeenanPhiladelphia Flyers | Jacques Demers |
| 19841983/84 | Bryan MurrayWashington Capitals | Scotty Bowman, Gerry Cheevers |
| 19831982/83 |   Orval TessierChicago Blackhawks | – |
| 19821981/82 | Tom WattWinnipeg Jets (1979) | – |
| 19811980/81 | Red BerensonSt. Louis Blues | – |
| 19801979/80 | Pat QuinnPhiladelphia Flyers | – |
| 19791978/79 | Al ArbourNew York Islanders | – |
| 19781977/78 | Bobby KrommDetroit Red Wings | – |
| 19771976/77 | Scotty BowmanMontréal Canadiens | Tom McVie |
| 19761975/76 | Don CherryBoston Bruins | – |
| 19751974/75 |   Bob PulfordLos Angeles Kings | – |
| 19741973/74 | Fred SheroPhiladelphia Flyers | – |
